Dario, Marx, Fincher and Murnau

In the intricate tapestry of global cinema, characters and narratives frequently emerge as powerful vehicles for socio-political and ideological critiques. This striking capacity is notably evident in the oeuvre of David Fincher. The primary focus of this essay is Fincher's adaptation of "The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo" (2011), a gripping narrative weaving together threads of corruption and familial secrets, framed as a battleground of class struggle and capitalism.

Point: The characters of Lisbeth Salander and Mikael Blomkvist serve as emblematic representations of the marginalized and professionally discredited segments of society, respectively. They are placed in stark contrast to the bourgeois Vanger family, reflecting the critique of capitalism presented by Marx in Das Kapital. Evidence: This critique is epitomized in Marx's aphorism, "Capital is dead labor, that, vampire-like, only lives by sucking living labor, and lives the more, the more labor it sucks" (Marx, 1867, p.342). Explanation: The author contends that these contrasting dynamics in the narrative are illustrative of societal conflict, shedding light on the destructive nature of capitalism, which thrives on labor exploitation. Fincher's adaptation of "Fight Club" (1999) offers another potent example of cinema critiquing capitalism and consumer culture. The film's portrayal of disenfranchised masculinity and the critique of consumerism echo Marx's theories, reinforcing the author's argument.

Point: Fincher's adept manipulation of cinematic language employs visual elements to manifest Marxist themes. Evidence: The stark, desaturated color palette and meticulously composed wide shots symbolize the harsh realities of capitalist society. Explanation: The author posits that this visual portrayal serves as a metaphorical reflection of alienation and exploitation—essential aspects of Marx's critique of capitalism. Another illustration of visual symbolism can be seen in Fincher's "Zodiac" (2007). The film's oppressive atmosphere and chilling suspense subtly mirror the societal effects of fear and paranoia, often products of capitalist structures that prioritize competition and survival of the fittest.

Point: The author highlights that Fincher's methodology echoes elements of early German cinema, specifically in the works of F.W. Murnau. Evidence: Films such as "The Last Laugh" (1924) and "Nosferatu" (1922) employ high-contrast lighting, distorted angles, and symbolic mise-en-scène to portray socio-economic struggles. Explanation: These visual elements align with the Marxist understanding of class struggle, expanding the critique beyond narrative confines. Further expanding this discussion, the author identifies parallel themes in Fritz Lang's "Metropolis" (1927), a seminal film in German expressionist cinema. With its portrayal of the stark divide between the workers and the elites, the film serves as a dramatic critique of capitalism, reinforcing the author's argument.

Point: The Hegelian dialectic—a triadic progression involving thesis, antithesis, and synthesis—offers a deep-seated philosophical context to the discussion. Evidence: As described in Hegel's "Phenomenology of Spirit," this dialectical process is fundamental to the evolution of the 'Geist' or the collective spirit of society (Hegel, 1807). Explanation: In "The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo," the author proposes that the power dynamics between the proletariat and the bourgeoisie culminate in an upheaval reflecting this dialectical process. This synthesis is symbolized in Salander's character arc, embodying the proletariat uprising in Marxist theory. In addition to this, Fincher's "Se7en" (1995) provides another cinematic illustration of the Hegelian dialectic, with its exploration of the conflict between the two main characters and their eventual convergence towards a horrifying synthesis.

Point: "Nosferatu" offers an intriguing parallel, with its vampire protagonist embodying the exploitative nature of capitalism. Evidence: The vampire's act of draining the life force of his victims mirrors capitalism's exploitation of the working class. Explanation: This allegorical representation serves as a critique of the predatory instincts of capitalism and echoes the socio-economic critique in Fincher's films. Taking this further, the author posits that the vampire myth has often been used as a critique of capitalism, as seen in more contemporary films like "Let the Right One In" (2008). This Swedish film subtly uses the vampire narrative to explore themes of social exclusion and economic disparity.

Point: By intertwining these strands—Fincher's cinema, Marxist theory, early German cinema, and the Hegelian dialectic—the author proposes a more profound understanding of socio-political commentary within the cinematic landscape. Evidence: This holistic approach broadens perspective, underscoring how cinema operates as a mirror reflecting society. Explanation: By depicting socio-economic structures, ideological constructs, and collective consciousness, the author suggests that films like "The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo" transcend their narrative boundaries, contributing to the dialectical evolution of society's collective consciousness. The author's exploration of ideological underpinnings in films such as "The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo" reveals narratives that interrogate broader societal realities. They argue that the transformative power of cinema extends beyond its role as a medium for entertainment. It can challenge and potentially subvert prevailing socio-economic narratives, thereby influencing the 'Geist' and contributing to society's dialectical progression. 

Drawing on Rubén Darío's words, "A drop of ink may make a million think," they elucidate the transformative potential of cinema to stimulate change in our socio-economic structures (Darío, 1905).

M. A. Aybar

References: